Friday, March 31, 2023

Underground Wonder Bar Update – What Happened After Bar Rescue

Underground Wonder Bar before Bar Rescue

In 1989 musician Lonie Walker opened the Underground Wonder Bar in the city of Chicago, and the live music joint enjoyed success for almost 22 years. Lonie’s momentum was ground to a halt in 2011 when the bar’s building was sold to pave way for a development project and she was forced to borrow around $360 grand from family and friends so she could reopen Underground in the River North district.

The owner Lonie Walker

Lonie’s expenses were astronomically higher due to the district’s high rent. The kind of live music she played with her band failed to click with the district’s younger clientele and she also aligned Underground’s menu towards her vegan ways. She was too stubborn to make much-needed changes which not only repelled the patrons but also sapped what little motivation her employees had left.

With debts climbing up to almost half-a-million bucks and income bleeding red, Lonie’s son Jordan decided to call Jon Taffer and Bar Rescue for help.

Underground Wonder Bar on Bar Rescue

From the outside Underground Wonder Bar’s colorful and juvenile façade made it look like a pizza place for kids than a watering hole for adults, while the interior lacked any kind of sophistication. Lonie’s vocal talents were snooze-inducing and in the downstairs performance area Jordan’s spoken word was drowned out by his mother’s singing. Things became a lot weirder when Lonie and her bandmates whipped out small instruments and played around the bar. The archaic form of entertainment failed to excite anyone inside the bar other than Lonie and the other musicians.

The old exterior

Taffer entered the bar and noticed the presence of crayons and how disconnected Lonie was from reality. She pushed Taffer away as she wasn’t willing to let go of her dream for the sake of profit but Jordan chased the Bar Rescue host and showed willingness towards whatever changes Underground needed. The next day expert bartender Russell Davis taught the employees how to mix drinks with creative artistic expressionism by starting out with the Old Fashioned cocktail. Culinary connoisseur Crystal “Chef Pink” DeLongpre introduced a Chicago-style flatbread with strong cultural influences which Lonnie immediately met with hostility, claiming that it was laden with preservatives. Her claim was ironic considering how Underground served frozen pizza which was decked with the very same stuff she hated.

Taffer then had the staff paint Underground Wonder Bar’s exterior with white to signify a fresh beginning. During the stress test Taffer prohibited Lonnie from playing music and instead assigned her to managerial duties which she did with zero enthusiasm, contrary to Jordan’s hardworking nature. One of the bartenders named Ruby mixed drinks at an atrociously slow pace and even cussed at thirsty patrons who wondered when their drink will be served. The bar’s downstairs was severely underutilized with barely any customer paying a visit. Later on Lonnie kept herself busy by talking to friends and diverting her much-needed attention away from the bar’s problems.

After the test Lonnie was still her stubborn self which earned her another walkout from the Bar Rescue team, much to the frustration of Jordan who only had Underground’s best interests in mind. Taffer returned for one last try and Lonnie appeared to be willing to embrace change, and she and Jordan were made to sign a contract that prohibited them from changing the bar’s name for a year after the rescue. Jordan was then given the mantle of general manager which Lonnie accepted without resistance.

For the bar’s new concept Davis introduced the Clear Collins and the Art & Money Mule cocktails, both of which appeared very clear and pure on the glasses. The new food item was a non-cured bacon dish with a sprinkling of peanut brittle, maple syrup, and bullet bourbon.

The new outside

After 36 hours Underground Wonder Bar was torn down and rebuilt to Clear Bar with a clean white façade and windows that provided a view of the interior. The inside now screamed sophistication with brand new furniture, sound system, and an eye-catching ice block behind the counter as the area’s theme focused on the ice industry. The downstairs bar was now called The Count Room, a 30’s and 40’s era inspired area, and its previous dungeon-like feel was now breathed with new life thanks to the warm lighting on the walls and the simple yet catchy décor. Lonnie was at first ambivalent towards the changes but eventually she warmed up to Taffer and loved the new face of her bar.

Underground Wonder Bar Now in 2018 – The After Bar Rescue Update

The Clear Bar name didn’t last long and Lonnie returned the signage of Underground Wonder Bar despite the agreement she signed during the episode.

Underground Wonder Bar is still open and many of the things Taffer dropped were returned including the crayons on the tables and Lonnie’s live music gigs, but they did keep some and the owner reportedly loved the revamp in the lower level.

Change has come

The bar has a good amount of positive reviews on Facebook and Yelp. People loved the performances, customer service, and the atmosphere. A few pointed out that some of the drinks were expensive and weren’t anything special. They always have live performances and this April Underground will be having a Talent Search with a $1,000 grand prize.

Last January 2017 Underground announced that they were closing but for some reason the closure didn’t push through, although it is reported that the building is currently up for sale.

Underground Wonder Bar maintains an active Facebook page which you can visit by clicking here. Also here’s their Twitter and Yelp pages. You can also check out their official website at

Anthony Coyle
I write about anything and everything that catches my fancy, but mostly I try to provide the answers to the questions our readers ask every day. I'm also the guy who's always glued to an LCD screen of some sort.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Read